Best Pies in Manhattan, According to Seek

Nov 24, 2021 | Curators, Recommendations

Seek, a social app that lets users find unique and trusted recommendations from local, like-minded curators launched recently in the New York City Tri-state area. Today, we are sharing the best places to get your Thanksgiving pies in NYC!


Rec #1- Petee’s Pie Company

61 Delancey Street


Peetes Pie Company- Best Thanksgiving Pies NYC- Seek App

Petee’s makes their pies with seasonal local produce and natural fair-trade sweetener. The crust is made with organic flour and grass-fed butter from New York State. They even offer delicious gluten-free and vegan options! Health conscious pies? Bring it on.

Rec #2- Little Pie Company

424 West 43rd St

Little Pie Company- Best Thanksgiving Pies NYC- Seek App

Traditional with a modern flare is how we would describe Little Pie Company. Their gluten-free pies are out of this world! You can even order online for pickup or delivery through Gold Belly. From November through December, they offer a salted caramel apple pie with caramel drizzle on top. Take that home for the holidays and you will be sure to get the best seat at the table.


Rec #3- Four and Twenty Blackbirds

439 Third Ave, Brooklyn

Four and Twenty Blackbirds- Seek App- Best Holiday Pies

Started by two sisters in 2009, Melissa and Emily wanted to take things back to basics with seasonal and fresh ingredients, while providing a home feel in their stores. They like it when you stay, have a slice of pie, a coffee and take in the whole experience. Although the pandemic did not allow for that experience for over a year, their Third Ave location is now back open! 

Want more recommendations on great pie spots and NYC hidden gems?

Click here to download the Seek app on your iPhone or iOS device now!

About Seek

Seek is a content platform that connects tastemakers in the consumer leisure space with millions of consumers seeking trusted and relevant recommendations on where to eat, drink and spend their leisure time. Consumers have access to trusted and vetted recommendations from like-minded experts while tastemakers can showcase and monetize their expertise and passion. Seek currently has thousands of recommendations from tastemakers around the world.

A minority and woman led company, Seek is dedicated to diversity, equity and inclusion and showcasing expertise from experts across interests and personalities. No matter who you are, find and share what you like on Seek.

To learn more visit